Date: Mon, 4 Nov 2002 20:12:03 +0100 (CET)
From: Massimiliano Ghilardi <max@linuz.sns.it>
To: Adam Olsen <e-mail omitted>
Cc: twin-develop@lists.sourceforge.net
Subject: architecture of twin


I thought on what you said about putting widgets in the server,
and also about the discussion with PLD people on tha same topic,
and I came up with a nice (IMHO) idea: adding extensions to twin server,
to let it run arbitrary code in a controlled way, and in particular adding a
"libTT" extension, that will execute libTT functions on clients' request.

In this way clients have a twin server featuring a toolkit library,
but I do not want clients to have hardcoded, ad-hoc code to
exploit these features of twin, so I thought about writing two specialized
HW drivers for libTT: hw_twin_tunnel_c and hw_twin_detunnel_c, as you can see
in the diagram below (which enhances the diagram I previously wrote):


+---------------+   +-------------------------------------------------------------------+
| libTw clients |   |                            libTT clients                          |
+---------------+   +-------------------------------------------------------------------+
   |                                            |
   |                                            V
   |                +-------------------------------------------------------------------+
   |                |                         libTT (libs/libTT/)                       |
   |                +-------------------------------------------------------------------+
   |                                            |
   |                                            V
   |                +-------------------------------------------------------------------+
   |                |                libTT HW drivers (libs/libTT/HW/hw_*_c)            |
   |                +-------------------------------------------------------------------+
   |                  |        |             |             |                  |
   |                  V        V             V             V                  V
   |   +----------------+  +---------+  +----------+  +----------+   +------------------+
   |   |hw_twin_tunnel_c|  |hw_twin_c|  | hw_gtk_c |  | hw_X11_c |   |hw_twin_detunnel_c|
   |   +----------------+  +---------+  +----------+  +----------+   +------------------+
   |                  |        |             |             |                  |
   V                  V        V             V             V                  |
+--------------------------------+      +----------+  +----------+            V
|     libTw (network library)    |      |  libgtk  |  |  libX11  |    cannot be used here
+--------------------------------+      +----------+  +----------+
 ^                         |
 |                         |
 |                         |
 ............. network...........................................................................................
 |                         |
 |                         |
 |                         V
 |   +----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
 |   |                                      twin server (server/)                                               |
 |   +----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
 |                                    |                                     ^                |
 |                                    V                                     |                V
 |   +-------------------------------------------------------------------+  |  +--------------------------------+
 |   |             server HW drivers (server/hw/hw_*.c)                  |  |  | server extensions (server/ext/)|
 |   +-------------------------------------------------------------------+  |  +--------------------------------+
 |        |       ^        |              |            |            |       |           |
 |        V       |        V              V            V            V       |           V
 |   +---------+  |  +------------+   +--------+   +--------+   +--------+  |  +------------------+
 |   |hw_twin.c|  |  |hw_display.c|   |hw_X11.c|   |hw_tty.c|   |hw_ggi.c|  |  |   ext_libTT.c    |
 |   +---------+  |  +------------+   +--------+   +--------+   +--------+  |  +------------------+
 |        |       |        |              |            |            |       |           |
 +--------+       |        V              V            V            V       |           V
                  |   +---------+     +--------+   +--------+   +--------+  |  +------------------+
                  |   |twdisplay|     | libX11 |   |  tty   |   | libggi |  |  |      libTT       |
                  |   +---------+     +--------+   +--------+   +--------+  |  +------------------+
                  |        |                                                |           |
                  +--------+                                                |           V
                                                                            |  +------------------+
                                                                            |  | libTT HW drivers |
                                                                            |  +------------------+
                                                                            |           |
                                                                            |           V
                                                                            |  +------------------+
                                                                            |  |hw_twin_detunnel_c|
                                                                            |  +------------------+
                                                                            |           |
                                                                            +-----------+


In this way, it is possible for libTT clients to create the widgets on either client or server
side, depending on runtime (!) parameters.

If $TTDISPLAY=twin then libTT clients use the libTT HW driver 'hw_twin_c', which (as it is normal)
internally create widgets, then uses libTw to draw them (using low level protocol) on a twin server.

If $TTDISPLAY=twin-tunnel then libTT clients use the libTT HW driver 'hw_twin_tunnel_c',
which only creates fake widgets internally, and uses libTw to tell the twin server to load
the libTT extension (which, for now, MUST use libTT HW driver hw_twin_detunnel_c) and use it
to create real widgets (high level protocol between client libTT and twin server libTT extension,
encapsulated by libTw extension mechanism),

then hw_twin_detunnel_c draws widgets on twin server itself using server native functions
(low level protocol):
this means there will be NO expensive network data transfers for widget related events
(expose, repaint, ALL mouse and keyboard activity, theme change, ...):
the only data passing across the network are client function calls (widget create/modify/delete)
and events for listeners on client side explicitly created by the client.


I hope you will like the idea,


Massimiliano Ghilardi


